Crayola Aroma Putty, Silly Putty Alternative, Gift Set, 4 Count

A great spin on the traditional silly putty. The pine scent was kind of yucky but the others were great. Depends on what scents you like. Great quality putty, great consistency and the scents were perfectly proportioned.

Great soothing product! Day one of using I would use gently, I believe I over used the item and my eyes got slightly irritated.. after the first day I can barely keep it out of my hand...bonus, it keeps your hands super soft and smelling nice! I work with dogs and sometimes large aquarium systems, don’t remember if there is an official warning/ caution... but I choose to wash my hands before handling food or dealing with aquariums.

I found these scented putty recently. The scent is very strong but pleasant and very long lasting. True to the scents listed on the items. I thought oh Christmas scents will be pleasing too. Not so much. None of them smell quite like I had expected. Peppermint, gingerbread, sugar cookie and pine. Anyway the putty is okay just not the scents I expected. A little more costly too.

The packaging was beautiful, and the containers were top-notch! I was so excited to get this as we are big fidgety people in my house and we used the silly puddy we got from the store till it was ruined. You can see the size is good and the consistency is what you expect, but the smell is hideous I expected Christmas in a container from the reviews I saw online. Instead, I got a refinery worker after a 12-hour shift in hot conditions. Maybe it was bad, there was no pine, no candy cane, no sugar cooking, and no ginger. I got plastic, more plastic, and worse plastic. When you close the containers, the smell stays inside, but what good does that do! I threw the packaging away, or it would be going back!! I had high anticipations, So disappointing. My family even asked where the old stuff was because no one wanted to touch it from the smell.

I was so excited about these and had thought they might work well for additions in a teacher gift bag. However I’m sad to report that while I found the putty itself to be as expected, the smells were no good. The scents seemed to have mixed in the packaging perhaps. I spent about 15 min each kneading and stretching each one to see if they could be improved. Minor improvements resulted in the following notes: Pine is completely unidentifiable, gingerbread is not as expected, though at least mild, candy cane has some peppermint mixed in with whatever other scent, and the sugar cookie smells powerfully as expected. Additionally, two of them, especially the gingerbread one, seemed to have separated and have clear plastic beaded on it and leaked out of the case, making it very difficult to open. It was able to be incorporated back in with kneading. I’ve never had that problem before with silly putty.Unfortunately, I had to cancel another order and will be returning these. Great idea, but execution is off.

These were a great addition to my DIY calm down box for my daughter.

I had high hopes for the sugar cookie sent, it honestly smelt burnt. Like seriously burnt.The gingerbread smelt good, but it smells exactly like the cinnamon scent they have, just a different color. The candy cane is the exact same as the peppermint, color and all. And the only one that was new was the pine, it smelt okish, reminded me of my grandmas house really. The texture of the putty was ok, some where more firm and others soft. The texture js really similar to that of bubble gum, just not sticky

Love the smell and to sit and play with the putty!

I have had these for 6 months and they smell the same as when I opened them. I actually would have preferred a softer scent as my co-worker two offices over can tell when I am working through a problem!

We bought this for our daughter who needed something to do with her hands. She loves the smell of these. As others have said, the scent is quite strong, but I imagine it will wear down with time. The putty was strong and really great for her to grip in her hands.

Beautiful containers and a variety of scents. Some smells are more powerful than others. Coconut is very calming and not too overwhelming. Lavender is quite strong smelling. Cloves is quite overwhelming and way stronger than it needs to be. Scents could be more subtle and would be more affective, as they are they are actually too overwhelming to be calming.

UPDATE:There’s obviously some QA issues at the factory. A second “Brand new” box sent to me, open the tea tree one and SAME THING (see second picture)! There’s finger prints in the putty and obviously messed with again! Someone at the factory had been touching these bare hand or they are repackaging used putties!Please see 3rd picture to see a brand new putty and compare!Will never buy again! :(———————————————-Received package. Most items are fine. However opened the tea tree (light blue) one and was shocked the putty seems used (obvious fingerprint seen as per picture), and giving off awful smell…Contacting seller.