S.he Makeup 24Pcs Shimmer Eyeliner

I was shocked by how much this product sucked because the black eyeliner 24 count is so awesome. The black set has a stiff felt applicator tip that allows you to make a neat thin line. This color set has a flimsy brush applicator that makes the eyeliner go everywhere. I might as well finger paint on my eyelids. But the worst part is that even after applying several layers, you can barely see the eyeliner. Even the black color is almost invisible. The black 24 count in this same brand is amazing. It is dark,makes a clean thin line that lasts all day. It really is waterproof and smudge proof.