K palette Real La stain Guay liner 24hWP SB001

I have no reason to believe I didn't receive a genuine product, but this doesn't live up to the hype for me. I have slightly hooded eyes, and I wear sharp, precise, black liner on a daily basis. I've tried all kinds, but I went on the hunt for the most long-lasting product I could find and decided to give this a try. I don't usually have any trouble with transferring, as my eyelids just aren't that oily. But I wanted to be able to use this during warm weather, with sunscreen on my face, and potential sweating and/or eye watering.Firstly, this isn't waterproof. At all. If my eye waters a tiny bit and I dab it gently (without rubbing) this just comes right off on the tissue. Not only that, but it is then GONE from that area of my lid. So it's not just a little transfer, which I can handle. Also, this melts when I sweat, and just in general throughout the day. Over a day's wear, it becomes patchy and less opaque.Finally, I just hate the brush. To be fair, my preference is for fine felt tip liners, but I do own many brush types and gels that I apply with a separate brush. So while I don't love a brush, I do know how to use one. The brush on this is so long and flexible that it requires an unusual amount of dexterity to get it to behave the way I expect it to. The slightest pressure change results in a wildly uneven line.The brush is so long that it has a tendency to dry at the tip, requiring varying amounts of pressure to get the product to flow. You can shake it, or dip it in a little water, but doing so causes the product to drip out at the sides of the brush, potentially making a big mess of your hand or face. If you don't do this, it'll drag until the product reaches the tip making the line jagged and uneven. I suppose you could also press it on your hand over and over, but again, this makes a mess of your hand.The highly variable amount of product coming out of the brush also means that sometimes it applies nice and black, and other times it's kind of sheer and you have to keep going over it. Sometimes, way too much makes it onto the brush, and I end up with a glob of black that I have to allow to dry to avoid smearing it everywhere.I argue with this product every time I apply it, and doing so significantly increases the amount of time I need to spend applying liner, which is pretty ridiculous considering that I've been doing it almost every day for many years. I'll use this up, because it's not bad looking once it's on (although it's about as durable as any non-waterproof liquid liner), but I'll skip it for any occasion that requires water resistant performance. At least it removes like a dream. It comes off in a single swipe with a makeup wipe or a cotton pad with eye makeup remover.

TLDR: I like it, but I'm not sure if it's the product I thought I was purchasing. It's not waterproof enough for my oily eyelids, so I probably wouldn't purchase this again.In the description:"Super water proof / Luquid [sic] typeEasily remove by lukewarm water."?????? I'm unsure how super waterproof also means easily removable by lukewarm water. Anyway, I have really oily eyelids. While this eyeliner does stay on for a good amount of time (a solid 8 hours), if I was to just *pat* my eye with a thin napkin at the end of the day, it would remove some product. If I was to swipe my finger on the eyeliner with some of the oil my skin produced, the eyeliner would be removed. So no, it's not a holy grail item. However, for what it's worth, I love the super black, matte ink. I love the brush tip. I purchased this back in November 2016 (it's February 2017), and it's still alive. Though the ink isn't what it used to be (it's kind of watery now?), it's still very easy to use and still very pigmented.

Eyeliner and doing the cat eye is something I have been doing since I was in 8th grade so finding a good liquid eyeliner is key for me. This product works really well. It really does stay on all day. I usually have an issue with my liquid eyeliner smudging throughout the day but this stuff does not at all.The only Con is the tip tends to "dry" quickly while I am using it. When I do one eye I run out of eyeliner to finish the other. I try to shake it but it doesn't come up quickly so I have to stop and let it refill the tip. But other than that it works and stays on great!

I am a liquid eyeliner addict. This means that over the years I've tried many different products, mostly drugstore. I just can't stand the thought of spending 20 dollars on eyeliner, only to find out that it's mediocre. I was able to swatch this product when I stumbled upon it in an Asian beauty store & I was absolutely impressed. One of the main reasons I was so impressed was because the tip of the pen stayed inky. Those of you that have used felt tip liquid eyeliner pens know what I'm talking about. I decided to "splurge" ordered it online with high hopes that this eyeliner would be able to keep its tip in shape and inky.I've used this eyeliner several times now with great results, and the tip of the felt pen has been able to keep it's shape & is still inky as ever. I can say with confidence that, I'm absolutely in love with this liner & I've actually recommended it to several people already. The finish of the product is a little bit shiny, not really matte, but you can just dust it with a little bit of translucent powder which takes away the shine and helps it stay in place/last longer. Now the product already lasts a long time, but I've never tested out it's water proof ability so you can take the gamble if you'd like. All in all, definitely a product I'd recommend if you want winged eyeliner sharp enough to kill someone.

I have always had trouble finding a good eyeliner because I have oily eyelids. I thought this eyeliner would do the trick because of the hype, but it has, unfortunately, disappointed me. On eyelids with primer, it is very transparent and sometimes doesn't even show up. However, it works well with eyeshadow underneath, but still smudges off after a few hours. I would not recommend this product to people with oily eyelids. Nevertheless, it has a very precise pen that feels like an actual pen, and when it does work the color is pretty dark.

It wasn't exactly what I was expecting but I was expecting a miracle lol. The wear was about the same as the sephora brand but of course the price was much better. I also like the incredibly thin line. I had to go over my line about 3 times to get the thickness I wanted which I considered pretty standard and thin, but this makes it very easy to hide mistakes.