Starry Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner Gel with Brush Black Asphalt, 3g/0.11oz

This liner does smudge quite a bit, but I have figured out that if you wet the brush and apply it sparsely as you would with watercolor, it doesn't smudge at all and you still get a rich color.

brush is not of a v great quality, i use a previous eyeliner brush. You get what you pay for.

I have asymmetrical eyes. My right eye has a slight thicker double-lid than my left eye. So, I always find it so hard to use eyeliner pencils to make 'em look the same. But with this product, it takes whole a lot of stress off from my shoulders by providing smooth and precise application. The brush is much easier to handle on my eyes, and it really last long. However, when you first apply it on your eyes, it's crucial that you dry them off, or else, that gel will get all over the place. Try to dip just the tip of your brush into the gel so that you can get the minimum amount of gel on it. Over dipping will make it harder for you to not get smudged.

It works, but it is not long lasting. By the end of the work day, I look like I have raccoon eyes. The color is correct, but the texture of the product is a little greasy, and smears so easily. If you use it to line the bottom, be aware if any of the liner gets on your lashes, you will have lash marks on your face all day.

This product was decent. It goes on really creamy, but it's also kind of heavy. I was excited to have an eyeliner that would stay on my waterline, but it fell down in seconds. It will stay for about 4 hours, but then start to run or smear. Other than that, it's actually a pretty good eyeliner, especially for a gel. The brush that comes with it is very good about only using a little bit of the gel to go a long way, so it'll last practically forever. I would suggest only using this on the top lashline, though, so it won't run and make you look like a raccoon.

Not a bad buy for the price, but not the waterproof I was looking for. Description states that it is waterproof, but after about 2 hours, it's barely there. It tends to bleed onto the upper eye as well. Think I'll stick with M-A-C.

This is an okay eyeliner. It's very creamy and the brush that comes with it is awesome. I've used it to line my top and bottom lids. It doesn't work so well on the bottom (runs after an hour or so) but on the top it looks good and lasts a long time. You also don't need to use a lot of it, a small dab is enough to line your whole lash line, so one pot will last you ages. Be careful about how much you use as it can get heavy and smear if you use to much. Overall I was pretty happy with it.

I 'bent' the brush that came with it to make application even easier. This eyeliner goes on very smoothly and a little goes a very long way! If you don't use a foundation on your eyelid and put a little shadow or powder over the liner it will mark your eyelid crease but I always wear foundation and shadow on my lids and don't have a problem. I have not used on my water line but I would guess it would not stay well. Overall this is a good gel and a great value.