Meow MixOcean Explosion Cat Treat [Set of 12]

The ONLY reason I'm saying "okay" I because someone gave me a bag of this flavor, and my cats loved it. Then I couldn't find it anywhere in the stores - and looked in a bunch. Then when I did find it, I was so excited. THEN, my cats just kind of turned up their noses at it. This is Tartar Control, and I'm thinking that must be why? I'm just guessing because they're not talking, and they're not eating these! I had to order a bunch too - agh! I kept a few and gave some to my uncle who has cats. The ones I kept are still taking up space in the kitchen. Sigh ...