Where Men Win Glory: The Odyssey of Pat Tillman

Krakauer once again tells a very engaging, wide-ranging, complex story of an interesting and unusual character. The book switches back and forth between the life of Tillman and the events in the world and especially Afghanistan, as they (in hindsight) inexorably grind toward that day when all the stories intersect on the battlefield and result in Tillman's death. It's brilliantly done and I think you will love it. Much of my review will be made in reaction to some of the complaints against the book: Because I specifically disagree with them, in detail.Some have complained that this book is either not a well-told story or not up to Krakauer's usual standards. To me, this is nonsense. This book was every bit as much a page-turner as any other of his books. The way he weaves the story of Afghanistan, US policy and actions, Al Qaeda's increasingly bold series of attacks, and Tillman's life is skillful and does not come off as contrived as it so easily could have. Krakauer frequently makes direct linkages in time between Tillman's life and events in Afghanistan (and elsewhere), for instance on p. 79, "In the predawn hours on the day of that game, as Pat was asleep in his hotel room, a Toyota delivery truck appeared at the entrance to a parking lot behind the American embassy in Nairobi, Kenya."The history of Afghanistan Krakauer provides, admirably brief, is needed to set the stage on which Tillman will eventually play. (I have read extensively on Afghanistan and the rest of central Asia; and, based on my conversations with others, the vast majority of Americans need this historical overview to make sense of the events in the book.) This is not a narrowly-focused biography of Tillman that plops him (surprise!) into an unknown Afghanistan to die in a meaningless way. Setting the stage in Afghanistan gives great meaning to flow of events that brought him there and his motivations. In spite of the complaints that it's not a straight biography of Tillman (it wasn't intended to be), it chronicles Tillman's post-adolescent life, especially his post-enlistment life, in great detail (almost too much for me.) There are frequent long quotes from his journals. Many direct quotes of Tillman's own public and private statements. Frequent quotes from interviews with his friends, family, wife, coaches, roommates, fellow students, fellow soldiers, his commanders. I doubt more detail could have been written about his service in the army and still remain readable.Many of the negative comments on the book complain about Krakauer's "criticism of the Bush Administration." A book about a man whose death was part of a large public cover-up and whose very exposure to combat was part of a controversial set of geo-political actions by the US Administration (our first preemptive war, for one thing, a decision that will haunt us into the distant future), inevitably MUST be in part political. However, the plain facts about who took what decisions and the results of those decisions are laid out in a very dispassionate way. In no way does the book devolve into a political diatribe. (Anyone familiar with Krakauer's writing knows that understatement is one of his strengths.) Some of those decisions were clearly bad blunders. I'm sure that burns in certain political quarters. Bush, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, Cheney, et al. are rarely mentioned. Clinton comes off as a weak CinC, crippled into inaction against Al Qaeda by his affair with Ms. Lewinsky. All of our failings come off looking bad, because of course they were bad. We did fail, as a nation, to react correctly to Al Qaeda and the Taliban. These are plain facts.Several reviewers have commented that Krakauer, since he is not a combat veteran, cannot have the perspective to make any valid commentary on the actions of men in combat. I respectfully assert that this is nonsense. He can't give a soldier's personal perspective; but there is a long and distinguished history of non-military writers on military subjects, including personal combat. Mainly they do it by interviewing soldiers and reading their journals: Which is exactly what Krakauer has done. I refer the reader to Blackhawk Down by Mark Bowden, Thomas Ricks' Making the Corps, and John Keagan's books, in particular The Face of Battle, among many other excellent books on combat (or being a soldier) by non-combatants.The Face of Battle (Hardcover)Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War [ILLUSTRATED] (Hardcover)Making the Corps: 10th Anniversary Edition with a New Afterword by the Author (Paperback)Krakauer has made some quite extreme technical climbs in remote mountains. I have never been in the military nor in combat (I'm grateful to say.) However, one of my closest climbing partners of many years was one of the LRRP soldiers in Vietnam: They were dropped behind enemy lines in small groups every 10-14 days to search and destroy for 4-9 days at a time. He saw plenty of "action." He tells me that the only thing that had the intensity of combat is the intensity and peril of difficult technical mountaineering (at least this was true for him.) He also noted that the camaraderie of the rope was comparable to the unit cohesion of the military: The trust and comradeship. I met Krakauer on Mt. McKinley while he was soloing the mountain: He's a solid customer and quite bold. I can say for myself that difficult, exposed climbing in remote places have been the most riveting experiences of my life. You get completely into "the zone" where nothing is in your mind except the here and now, this concrete second in your life. The comradeship and trust of the rope are peak experiences. Your partner, their hands on your rope, literally holds your life in their hands. The point is: Krakauer does have some perspective on life-and-death high-stress situations, even if he hasn't been in combat.Some have complained that Krakauer notes Tillman's lack of religion: "I am also unclear as to why Krakauer feels the need to tell everyone Tillman was an agnostic/atheist" This is bizarre to me. Would they be complaining if it were noted that Tillman were a Christian (he wasn't)? Is one's religious stance not important to one's motivations? Are not Tillman's motivations for enlisting some of the main points of his story? There are two pertinent quotes:p. 34 "[in his diary, Tillman] opined that religion was inadequate to elucidate the mysteries of existence."p. 116 "But there was more to his decision than he shared with ESPN. Pat was agnostic, perhaps even an atheist, but the Tillman family creed nevertheless imparted to him an overarching sense of values that included a belief in the transcendent importance of continually striving to better oneself - intellectually, morally, and physically."And there is also:p. 16 "When [Tillman and his brothers] had to be indoors, they engaged in clamorous discussions about current events, history, and politics with their parents and each other. Almost no subject was off-limits. Encouraged to think critically and be skeptical of conventional wisdom, Pat learned to trust in himself and be unafraid to buck the herd."These all seem quite on topic in a discussion of Tillman's life and what motivated him to enlist in the army. Many American Christians seem to believe that none of their non-co-religionists are in possession of morals or proper values (viz.: Lt. Col. Kauzlarich, pp. 314, 315). The point is directly pertinent to that attitude.

The book was very well written with insights into Pat Tillman's life early on and through his football career into Army life. The book expresses the deep devotion of Tillman to his wife, his brother and to his family. I recommend the book highly.That said, having driven those extremely dangerous canyon river trails of eastern Khost entering Khost City/FOB Salerno (mid 2003) from the east, I can say with absolute certainty how daunting the terrain is in that part of Afghanistan. The dried creek beds double for "roads"; as the sun goes down, the shadows from the overhangs in the dried riverbeds makes one wonder not "if" but "when" the ambush will commence-will I die today!From a tactical standpoint, the 1LT on the ground has the correct understanding of the issues-not to separate what was Serial One and Serial Two for the purpose of retrieving a broken Hummve. Numerous attempts to convince the TOC at FOB Salerno were of no avail, and as such, the result was Tillman's tragic death by friendly fire, the death of the ANA soldier and the wounding of two or more others.The rule..."the man on the ground knows best" should have been the decisive factor when ordering the Ranger unit to split into two parts (Serial One and Two). The decision was the foundation for causation of the KIA and WIA on that riverbed in eastern Khost Province, Afghanistan.At the time of Tillman's death as so well documented in the book, the other Rangers knew then of the friendly fire incident. Upon returning to FOB Salerno, all were told to "keep quiet" about the incident..it was a direct order (actually a fraudulent order).Who gave the order to destroy Tillman's BDU uniform, his IBA (individual body armor), his Kevlar helmet and other personal effects leads the reader to believe the battalion commander, LTC Bailey was directly responsible in concert with the chain of command to include, COL Nixon, the commander of the 75th Rangers and JSOC commander and now current commander/Afghanistan, General McChrystal. Perhaps one day, we will know the truth-It was a disgrace the commanders in Tillman's chain of command were not truthful. And as such, they bring dishonor on all who have served and those who serve today. Duty, honor..country.. and truth.. was obviously not the standard given Pat Tillman, Tillman's family or the American public of the facts into Tillman's tragic death.The book is well worth reading, especially for those who want to understand why men respond to the calling. In Tillman's case, his calling involved the abandonment of a professional football career and millions of dollars- a true patriot and a name in the US Army that we shall never forget.

One of the most interesting and challenging books I've ever read. A book of truth where the word "they" is seldom used. The best review I can provide on this book is this...."Do yourself an enormous favour and buy yourself this book". It will be one of the best books you have ever read.

The shocking thing for me was that a professional army (supposedly the best in the world) could be so disorganized as to cause A10 Warthogs to bomb and strafe one it's own units (albeit one that had got lost and strayed well off the route it was supposed to be on), and another to machine gun it's own soldiers leading to the death of Pat Tillman and an Afghan soldier.As each disaster is carefully unpacked for us by Krakauer, all I could do was shake my head in despair as the litany of stuff-up's unfolded. FUBAR and SNAFU indeed.And the other thing was the cover up, whereby the Administration tried to take advantage of the tragedy by suggesting Tillman had been killed by insurgents. This was utterly disgraceful and they should have known better.However, I think the book is not entirely balanced in it's treatment of Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and the commanders who caused the several tragedies to unfold. For example, it's doubtful a Democrat administration wouldn't have tried to cover Tillman's death up, and/or try and make the most of it for propaganda purposes.Still a great read, and if you want to be tormented by 'friendly-fire' incidents, this book is for you!

Great book, Krakauer is a great story teller. In this book he tell us the story of Pat Tillman a football player that enlisted in the army after 9/11 to fought Al Qaeda and met a tragic death in Afghanistan by friendly fire. The author uses the plot to reveal a corrupt administration that put all its efforts into deceiving the north americans about the truth behind the Afghanistan and Iraqi war.The book is a “must have” for those that appreciate critical thinking and don’t buy everything that’s put in front of them.

He estado dudando entre tres y cuatro estrellas. Le pondría tres y medio si se pudiera. El libro no me ha gustado tanto como otros del mismo autor, en particular Mal de altura y Hacia rutas salvajes. Krakauer se siente atraído por personajes especiales que realizan acciones aparentemente incomprensibles que no responden a lo que la sociedad entiende como "normales". Desde este punto de vista me sentí más identificado con alguien como Alexander Supertramp, que huye de todo para buscar vivir salvajemente en la naturaleza, que con Pat Tilmann, que abandona una carrera en el fútbol americano para ingresar en el ejército de Estados Unidos. La historia resulta amena mientras se trata la vida de Pat Tilmann, pero decae considerablemente cuando trata de la guerra de Irak y, en particular, de la batalla de Nasiriyah, para volver a recuperarse con la narración de la muerte de Tilmann y el aprovechamiento y la guerra sucia de los políticos y militares de más rango. Creo que el libro está más dirigido al público estadounidense que al europeo. La primera parte exige cierta familiaridad con los conceptos básicos del fútbol americano y en especial con las posiciones dentro del campo. La segunda parte exige conocimiento de los nombres de las armas de guerra e incluso de algunos políticos y militares norteamericanos. Son buenos los apuntes históricos sobre Afganistán, pero en un punto se interrumpen esos apuntes, pienso que inapropiadamente, y, en ese sentido, el libro queda algo cojo. Concluyendo, el libro está bien y se deja leer, aunque, como digo, me atasqué en el capítulo de Nasiriyah, hasta el punto de que pensé en abandonar. Agradezco no haberlo hecho. Lo recomiendo para seguidores incondicionales de Krakauer, pero solamente si se sienten atraídos por una biografía que combina fútbol americano con guerra.

Sensational. A superb and tragic story that is beautifully written. Krakauer has a great sense of pace and rhythm and a wonderful vocabulary. The story of Tillman is just a few stray bullets away from being a quintessential American hero story. A pro athlete turned special forces soldier is almost comic book perfect, and should have been the ultimate chest-puffing source of pride for the United States Army. Fate turned out differently for Tillman and his family, and Krakauer's efforts do the memory of Pat Tillman a wonderful service. A must-read for anyone with the vaguest interest in the military.