STACY ADAMSMen's Garrison Wingtip Oxford

UPDATE: You can see my original review below, but be advised: After about 4 months of wearing and enjoying this shoe, the heel, for lack of a better term, "exploded," pulling away from the rest of the shoe and making any more wearing of the shoe impossible. I loved the look and feel of these shoes but the cheap build quality of the heel (hollow rubber) makes these shoes impossible to repair. I can't stand behind this brand or product any longer, as I need shoes that will last more than a few months.ORIGINAL:High-quality, daily shoes for me, which is saying a lot. I have pretty wide feet and practically no arches (thanks genetics!) so it's tough for me sometimes to find shoes that fit. When these shoes arrived, they felt pretty snug from a width standpoint, even at a 3E size, which was a new experience for me. Tennis shoes at a regular Medium width seem to fit me fine. However, after a day of wearing the shoes to break them in, I found incredibly comfortable shoes in this pair. The two-tone is very distinct and gets me compliments daily. I am impressed at the quality especially given the sub-$100 price. I plan to buy more of the same style/brand in the future, as these really impressed me. I am tough to fit but these did the trick.

Good looking shoe but it's not as described on the website. Website says leather upper but on the tongue it says "Leather with man made upper". Then below it "Leather lining". That tells me that the upper is NOT leather. After walking around in them for, like, 10 minutes, I noticed the creases on top of the shoe verified that it wasn't leather. Overall fit was not that great either. I'm going to return these and pay a little bit more for Johnston & Murphy brand shoes.

After a few days of wearing them. A few details stood out that slipped by me at first. Because I was too excited to have them.1st of all, I own SEVERAL pairs of Stacy Adams shoes and generally trust the brand. But something is not right about these. The broque on the toe, for one. The tightly narrow uncomfortable feel in the foot. The leather, suede, lining inside. They are not real leather. They may not be real, authentic Stacy Adams shoes, either.The soles are odd. Seem to be wearing out quickly. I am not sure that I like these shoes at all. So I looked over some of the worst reviews. Well... I am afraid these may be a waste of money. But we shall see, before my return window closes. I would not recommend them, in either case.PS: RETURNING...

Shoes looked nice. Unfortunately I ordered wide but still too tight. The sad part that I never saw anything on the listing that returns were not free. This made it hard for me to try a larger size. What if they didn't fit either. Now I'm out 2 shipping fees. Made buying shoes here a bit more of a hassle. Will shop elsewhere.

Not very happy... had this pair for 2 months. Only wore a couple times each week before the sole fell off. Had 2 other pairs that both lasted well over a year. Very disappointed that this show fell apart after only 2 months. And unfortunately the return window has passed. Might have to think about another brand unless this can be fixed... just very disappointed since my other Stacy Adams pairs lasted so much longer.

Great shoes...have the congac color I was looking for that matches many of my belts and watches. Can’t really review a shoe as it’s a highly personal item and everyone’s feet are different. These break in fast and wear well. I’m on my 4th pair on maybe 3-4 years and only cause I walk funny and/or end up doing something silly that hurts the shoe. I have a few different styles from Stacey Adams and have always been satisfied with the quality and value for my dollar spent

I wear an 11.5 in running shoes, and generally a 12 is going to fit comfortable. This is just a bit small in the vamp of the shoe. I wouldn't want any shorter, though. It's not going to last me 20 years, it's quality isn't on par with a vintage Florsheim Imperial, but you're not paying that kind of price.All things considered, it's a solid shoe, as long as the price is good.

This shoe is the only shoe I've ever purchased online for which the size indicated was patently wrong. This shoe is super narrow and way too long. I'd day it's about an inch or two too narrow and about 3 or 4 inches too long. It's so badly out of proportion it's comical. The brogue pattern was pretty nicely done, however. Still..had to return it.

These shoes look a lot more shiny and "fake" in person than pictures led me to believe. A stamp on the underside of the tongue also says: "Leather with manmade upper. Leather lining. Made in China." So these aren't 100% leather construction. There was also glue residue on the inside of the shoe at the heel, which didn't inspire confidence in their craftsmanship either.These shoes are comfortable to wear with some arch support, but fit and feel are about the same as my old $50 Dexter pair from Payless Shoe Source. I was also surprised by a fairly low instep for such a wide shoe. My feet are "low volume" (wide but not tall) and I had a tiny pressure point at the top of the shoe.I then put these shoes next to my Florsheim Classico Oxford Cap pair (they're made by the same company) and the difference in looks, material quality and construction is night and day. I expected some difference since that pair is twice the price, but still not this dramatic. Very disappointed as I really wanted to like these.

Cuando me llegaron y los probé tuve un problema, pues no entraba el pie al zapato, como que quedaban chicos, tuve que usar un calzador y ahí me dí cuenta que de largo eran perfectos, pero cuesta que el pie entre a la primera, habrá que aflojarlos un poco.Eso sí, recibí muchísisisimos halagos pues gustan mucho; tienen buenísima calidad y una plantilla de foam que los hace excelentes para caminar.Primera vez que compro la marca, de ninguna forma la última.

The shoes look like they're made with plastic but for $30 I can't really be complaining. I have purchased these in the cognac prior to this one and i agree they are not the best pair available in the market but they are nothing like these. It's not even real leather, even though it's printed on the tongue - manmade upper unlike what is advertised. But again, I can't expect much for this price and just felt that the advertising should be accurate and not false.

for this brand, you'd expect good quality product, and this one was the exception. definitely not worth the buy, and would advise against it.

Sole became loose on left shoe after 2 months and shoe lace on the right shoe broke. Otherwise, it was great while it lasted. Not worth taking to shoe store to fix properly. Glued it back the best I can.