Sumita Cosmetics Eyeliner Pencil (Brown)

I absolutely love this eyeliner in brown but I too have noticed it dries out midway. When I try to sharpen it, the product breaks off and almost falls out of the pencil. I have to sharpen it way more than I should have to just to get to the product which results in a LOT of waste. This has literally happened to me with every pencil that I buy. At $19 each, I don't consider this cheap. I contacted Sumita hoping they would give me a credit but instead they suggested I buy their sharpener to ensure it is being sharpened correctly. I still give it a 4 though as the liner goes on smoothly, stays put all day and washes off easily.

This is a great eyeliner. It goes on so easy and I am not good at it if it doesn't! It looks great. I have the brown and the gold (gold does not look gold) They both wear well but it not like liquid eyeliner -it can come off much easier which is good at face wash time. But after I put it on I put eye shadow on top to help set it and I get no smearing.

I bought the eyeliner and their pencil sharpener and the pencil continuously broke. Although I liked the color, I will not buy the product again.

I love this eyeliner pencil! I have tried every pencil under the sun for my waterline and tightlining. This is the only one that absolutely does not smudge on my oily skin. unfortunately it dries out at its midway point. However, I continue to purchase because I can't find anything else that works so well. I just keep 2 on hand at all times to make sure I never run out of the good part of the pencil.

I chose to buy this one because I had the black eyeliner a few years ago. I think the company might have changed the formula since then. This product is creamier and doesn't stay on as long as the other one I had, and less waterproof as well. overall, I would say its a decent eyeliner pencil.