Crib Mattress Protector Pad - Ultra-Soft Waterproof Breathable Premium Bamboo Rayon - Noiseless Fitted Dryer Safe Cover. High Absorbency Oeko-TEX Certified (28 x 52 x 9 inches) MARGAUX & MAY

I bought this mattress pad and the Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad (Fitted) - Very Soft, Quilted, NO VINYL, Fits All Standard Size Baby Mattresses, No Risk 100% Satisfaction Guarantee Crib Mattress Protector at the same time to put on my brand new crib mattress (you should always use a cover/pad!). I chose these because they are both budget-friendly and highly rated on Amazon. I wanted to compare the two and, if they were close to equal, keep them both so I'd always have a clean one on hand for unexpected middle-of-the-night bedding changes. I ultimately chose to return the Happy Little Mill (HLM) cover and will be buying another of one from Margaux & May (M&M). Had I only bought the HLM cover, I would have been happy enough and kept it. The M&M one was just a step above.The primary reason why I prefer the M&M is the sound factor. I had just purchased a memory foam mattress in part to get away from the plastic sounds of his older spring mattress. I didn't want the mattress cover to bring back the noise I had just eliminated. M&M is almost completely silent when you move around on it. HLM was noticeably louder though not terribly so. I also loved how soft the terry-cloth top of the M&M was. It gave it an extra little feeling of cush. The HLM has a plain fabric that is soft to the touch as well, but lacks that plush feeling of M&M. Lastly, neither had much of a smell and I could notice no plastic or chemical smell in the M&M after I washed it (I washed it before use).I didn't try putting the HLM on the mattress (I had already concluded it was going back) so I can't compare the two there -- but I can say that I was please with the snug fit of the M&M on my 5" deep foam crib mattress. I've washed it twice and used it for 6 weeks so far and I'm pleased with how it washes and how flat it lays on the bed. It's totally unnoticeable through the sheet, as it should be. There have been no issues with my son waking up sweaty or overheated as can sometimes happen when sleeping on a waterproof mattress cover. I have not yet had an occasion to observe it's waterproof claims but will certainly update this review if it fails to meet my expectations in that arena.Update: 4 months after my review and I still love this protector. Still no issues (but also still no incident to test leak-proof factor).Was this review helpful for you? If so, please click the "Yes" button below. If not, feel free to let me know why and I'll do my best to improve it. :)

This works great and is also soft, doesn’t make noise when laid on.

I went through many covers and this hands down has been the best. The top is very thick and soft, yet safe for baby. Once it is covered with a clean sheet, my son sleeps solid through the night. It has a clean and smooth fit. The barrier between his body and the mattress helps him stay comfortable as it is breathable and soft. It is completely waterproof and your mattress stays clean and dry. It has stood up to many, many washes and still like new almost a year later. I bought two to make sure I could always switch them out when soiled.

This fits perfect for my crib mattress and is also very easy to clean. It’s waterproof layer works well and did not bleed through.

very happy with product

This is a great mattress protector for a great price! I thought the top layer would be thin because it's water proof but it is a thick, fluffy, and soft for baby's comfort.

Worth for the money

They seem pretty nice.