Deliver to Romania
IFor best experience Get the App
Full description not available
M**H
Exactly what I was looking for
When I came upon this book I was searching for a definitive history of Zionism. I had read current histories on Israel and the Middle East, but I didn't have a deep understanding of where Zionism came from nor its philosophical impetus. I was looking for a book that would give me an unbiased account of where and why Zionism came to be, and in this one book I found it.Mr. Laqueur gives a detailed and clinical look into this phenomenon from its inauspicious beginnings to its improbable statehood and the many twists and turns in between. How he was able to go through and gather so much information on a movement that was so spread out and splintered between many different ideologies and theories is beyond me. He has assembled a wealth of information and presented it fairly and evenly.Zionism is a movement unprecedented in history and the affects of this movement are still being felt today. It seems that everyone has an opinion about Zionism, but it is important to have a deep understanding of where this movement came from before one can have an accurate picture of where it is now and why it has become what is. The more people understand about that past the more clearly they will see the present. This is an important book that needs to be read.
H**R
A Broad Look at a Unique Movement
I do not know where else in history that we have a people disposed from a land for two thousand years, scattered all over the world, who reconvene through an international movement and regain their homeland. I also can not recall any group suffering the violent and irrational hatred of so many nations as the Jews have.Lacqueur's history traces this unique movement. It's success was very fragile; the many decisions from world leaders could have gone much differently if made a few years sooner or later. Jews did not initially support it broadly; many prefered assimilation to their country of birth and some felt that the growing socialist movement provided a better answer to anti-Semitism. Even within the Zionist movement political infighting was strong.Yet the worst fears of those seeking a refuge from growing European anti-Semitism did not forsee the scope of the Holocaust, exterminating 6 out of 7 Jews in Europe. This emboldened the survivors and motivated just barely enough world sympathy to formulate the creation of the Jewish state.The reaction of the Arabs was neither surprising or unique in the course of developing nations. Lacqueur has the advantage of hindsight to examine policy mistakes and examine how it could have been different, but concludes the difficulty would have remained regardless.This examination shows Zionism not as a righteous holy ordained movement, nor is it a an evil racist colonial movement as the modern Arab media prefers to portray it. It was a politically and diplomatically unique solution to a very serious and unique problem.That the success of the Zionist enterprise has not yet yielded the peace they so desperately seek, makes this work only an introduction, but a valuable source to those seeking to understand the volatile Middle Middle East of the 21st century. There are many more chapters to be written.
M**Z
Superb Intellectual and Political History
This is by far the best single-volume history of Zionism, from the 1880s to 1948. Though a chronological history, it emphasizes the competing intellectual and political ideologies that competed with each other throughout the period. Zionism developed against the backdrop of sectarian politics in Europe and the Middle East -- nationalism, Communism, Socialism, etc. -- and there are long chapters on Jabotinsky and the Revisionists, on how Zionist leaders and intellectuals (usually the same people) dealt with the question of Palestinian-Arab nationalism, and on the dissenters and critics of Zionism within the Jewish world. Written in 1972, the book is remarkably balanced and fair-minded on questions relating to Arab nationalism, and to the competition between Labour Zionism and the Revisionists. There is very little, however, on Religious Zionism, which maybe be a function of Laqueur's own prejudices, or it's just that he doesn't see it as particularly relevant to the period he's focusing on. All in all, a dense, rich, fascinating read.
M**L
Best book
This is one of the best books anyone can read on the history of Zionism. It is also very well written -making it a pleasure to read. One can really understand the very serious problems which faced the Jews in Europe and Russia in the 19th century -and some of the questions they were dealing with enable one to understand some of the tensions which still exist in Israel.
B**N
Pure propaganda
Didn't read the whole thing, but plays on the narrative that Palestine was a "small community" at that time and how Israel is so great and they never treated anyone badly ever. Talks about pogroms of jews in Irak that never happened, the inhabitants of the land being Arabs and not Europeans, you will see that those claims of pogroms of Jews in the middle east never have a date or a citation. The Coran literally says God is good with the 12 tribes of Israel, there is literally no reason for a Muslim Arab to hate on a Jew Arab or a Chriatian Arab and in fact they cohabited in the region peacefully UNTIL sionism made Israel a thing and EUROPEAN jews came and stole the land via great britain at the time (1917, invasion of Palestine and Balfour declaration are 2 months appart. I literally read bits of it for 10 minutes and found so many contradictions.For ex. he says during the 1930s the zionist party didn't knew what it really wanted, but Balfour (a zionist) clearly expresses his wishes for zionism and another one much earlier in the late 1800 advocated for a Jewish state as a result of EUROPEAN anti Semitism. And if you look him up on Wikipedia, it says he worked with the CIA. Make of that what you wish
G**E
Ottimo
Ricostruzione completa della storia del sionismo. Un must per lo studio dell'argomento.
A**N
very detailed on the political!
If you are looking for an impartial, objective account of Zionism in relation to the Indigenous population of historic Palestine, then this book clearly isn't for you. Although very detailed in the political intrigues of the early Zioninst movement. There is less detail given to the conflict with the indigenous Arab & Christian population.Towards the end of the book the author mentions the Deir yassin masscre in a single fleeting sentence and then goes on to say, in the following paragraph, that 10,000 Arabs left, what was to become Israel in 1948. This, as any objective historian will tell you, is clearly incorrect, the number is now belived to be around 700.000, who were cleansed from the land.I did find it tragic that there was a movement within Zionism to work on an equal footing with the Indigenous population, but this was quickly sidelined by the more hardline elements within both communities.
Trustpilot
2 days ago
2 months ago