L'Oreal ParisMakeup Infallible Super Slim Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeliner, Ultra-Fine Felt Tip, Quick Drying Formula, Glides on Smoothly, Black, 0.03 fl oz., 2 Count

I previously purchased this product in a store and used it for nearly a year (I use for a very thin line) so thought this 2 pack would last so much longer. I've shaken these so any moisture would go toward the tip and stored on end but I haven't even gone as long as 1 store bought one. Disappointed. Will not likely buy online anymore.

This eyeliner is so easy to use and creates a clean natural line perfectly shaping each lid.

Really great liner. Has a long tip so easy to do a cat eye. Once you get it on you have a short window before it dries so mistakes have to be fixed quickly. Once it's dry, it will not budge or smear. I had a bit of smearing when I was removing it EOD but otherwise, it stays put all day. Bold color.

Easy to apply the liner. But it doesn’t last long and it flakes off into my eyes and all around my eyes. I’ve tried so many of these eyeliners none of them seem to work. It’s so annoying to look into a mirror an hour later and see black flecks all around your eye

Easy to apply and lasts!!

I have used this for years and I have tried many other brands including top brands and I still LOVE this one the best! It says it lasts 16 hours and I feel it could last even longer! It is smudge proof as long as you don’t touch your eyes or cry! It’s not waterproof, which is personally my favorite thing because I hate waterproof anything on my face. I like to wipe my makeup off within seconds not scrubbing my face forever! I get compliments on my makeup every time I wear it and everyone always asks me what I use and I share this with them. It glides on so easily and draws just like a nice 🖊️ pen! **The only problem I’ve ever had is that every once in awhile I’ll get one that’s dried out because when you try to put it on it barely comes out and you can tell because the top is stiff. Just contact them and get a replacement! Their customer service is fantastic!Anyway, hope this helps someone ☺️

Liquid and a fine brush. Comes off with Oil of Olay make-up removal sufficiently. Been using it for 4 years in the color black.

This is the best eyeliner I have found. It is great quality for a great price. Would highly recommend.

It’s really hard to trust reviews nowadays.I have been a long time user of more expensive eyeliners like Kat Von D Tattoo Eyeliner or Marc Jacobs Waterproof Eyeliner. I was excited to see this product for the price with such great reviews.I was looking forward to spending less and getting the same smudge proof quality as described in the reviews but unfortunately this eyeliner is terrible.It goes on great, it’s smooth and pigmented but with a slight touch even after 30 minutes it smudges and disappears. I often find myself having one eye with a wing because one side smudges off.I see why other brands charge more because the quality and promises of no smudging or being waterproof are true.Don’t even bother with this product.

Do you want to look like the next cover person of your favorite magazine? Could this be the product that could get the cat to look at you with absolute adoration for achieving the perfect cat eye that she herself can not achieve?Well, for me it wasn't. My makeup skills have always been lackluster, but the eyeliner itself is absolutely fantastic. The lines are great and it don't smudge. If I can wear it and look like a human being and not like like a slug whose trying to look pretty, then I bet that you can look SMOKING HOT too... even though you probably already are.

Only used for a few hours and definitely smudged around my eyes. Not worth it for the price But the felt tip applicator is good.

Excellent product extremley happy will be ordering again the only thing was the expense of p&p

I'm sure this eyeliner would normally be excellent, however, the one I received is COMPLETELY dried out! I went to use it the first time, And I could barely get it to even work. It's like it was left open for a couple weeks. I am VERY disappointed! I will probably try this eyeliner again, but I will go and buy it from a store. Beware ordering it from Amazon!