MILK BAR Cookie Variety Pack | Delicious Soft Baked Cookies With Unique Flavors | Trio of 3 Boxes w/ 8 Cookies In Each Box (Sweet n' Fruity Trio)

Completely blown away by how bad these cookies are. I've had their ice cream several times and it's delicious. But these cookies we're horrible. They are a lot smaller than I was expecting to begin with. They are a soft texture like it Chips Ahoy soft version cookie. They have a strong artificially sweet taste. It leaves a really bad aftertaste and almost slightly burns the back of your throat. I'm sure anyone familiar with that style of taste knows what I'm talking about. Such a waste of money

I love researching gifts and trying to pick the PERFECT one ... while sticking to a $25 budget that somehow never adjusts with income or inflation. My husband's cousin is in college, and I wanted to send him a birthday gift. But, like I mentioned, he's in college, and isn't the most responsive to desperate texts asking what he wants. Something about how he is studying, or has homework, or whatever.But I know dude has a sweet tooth. And, since sometimes I am a sheep, and am easily influenced by the New York Times, I found THESE COOKIES on Amazon. Which meant that I could indulge my "influenced into thinking Christina Tosi is super cool" with the convenience of Amazon delivery into a definitely-overpriced cookie pack for $20!Cousin reports that he expected to like the chocolate marshmallow ones the best, but ended up liking the ones with the fruity pebbles the best.24 cookies for $20 = $0.83/cookie. I guess that's a fair price.Yeah, I'd give a whole-hearted rec for these. Totally fits the "$25 gift budget" profile, has a "cool factor" if you're familiar with the Milk Bar / Christina Tosi rep, and has fun/unusual flavors if your recipient is a sweet toothed-foodie. - AM SIL

These are super gross . They taste like white chocolate. i was hoping for a more cookie taste

Ordered the Fruity trio variety pack hoping for something that tasted like... y'know? Fruity cereal? The confetti and the cornflakes ones sounded like they could at least be interesting. Unfortunately, i do not have words to describe the exact taste of any of these cookies. My roommate and I both had to spit out the fruity ones, they were so bad. The confetti were ... at least swallow-able, though I wouldn't eat one voluntarily again. The cornflakes were the closest to being truly edible, but that was mostly by comparison to the other two. Please, save your money and taste buds.

I liked the flavor but I felt like I was eating and I prefer a well cooked cookie so I decided to try cooking them for a few minutes at 350 and now they’re delicious!

These were phenomenal. I actually tried them with milk too even though I'm lactose sensitive. I would buy 2 orders because they went too fast. My favorite is the confetti cookie and I ended up buying many more. Yum!!!

Not good. Too sweet. Too artificial tasting. Ate one package of each flavor, gave away the rest as it was too sweet. Would not purchase again.

These are overly sweet with no depth of flavor. The sweetness actually takes over your mouth and genuinely hurts a little bit and leave a bad feeling in your mouth after you eat one. The confetti cookies don’t taste like anything but sugar, chocolate chip marshmallow cornflake cookies you can feel the cornflakes and yet have zero taste or a hint of saltiness that you need to cut through the pure sugar taste... even the chocolate chips were mild compared to the sugar. The size of the cookies are about the same size as a chewy chips ahoy.. for $20, please go buy the ingredients to make your own cookies or support a local bakery... do not buy these, I can assure you you will be diappointed!