ValueBull All Natural 12 Inch Regular/Thin Bully Sticks for Dogs, 50 Count

As mentioned in other reviews, these are very thin and last no longer than a few minutes. My dog is now shunning me. There are plenty of bully stick products that I have purchased in the past that last longer, smell better, and cost the same, like getting an Easter Reece's instead of a Cadbury egg. No one should have to eat a Cadbury egg. I would not recommend anyone purchase this product. Sad to think that the first review I've every written on Amazon was for such a terrible product, one that my dog got the bad end of the stick on, literally. Ok, that was a terrible pun and I should probably be stopped from writing reviews in the future, but these things do suck. Really bad. Huge waste of money. And maybe it's not sad, just ironic. Well, not really ironic, (is anything really ironic?) but just dreadfully, dreadfully awful.Oh, and to answer my own question, nothing is ironic. Unless it's in an Alanis Morissette song.

Make sure you read the description and look at the picture. They are small, about the size of a pencil as shown in the picture. They are meant for small dogs or could be used as a bite size snack for a large dog, meaning they will devour it in no time at all.

These sticks were truly a value, I mean they were cheap...These sticks were so thin that it took my dog 2-3 minutes to chew them gone. these would be for a Yorkie or tiny dog...maybe. There was no odor that I notice but they didn't last long enough to even asses that component of a review for Bully Sticks. The pencils in the picture do not accurately represent the actual size of these sticks either, maybe a ruler would be more appropriate to help understand dimensions of this product.

I was buying the huge Bully Sticks at Costco and the item was discontinued. I got these for my dog. She enjoys chewing them a lot. The only complaint is that they are really skinny when compared to Costco's.

We have purchased these 12 inch thin bully sticks for our 2 cocker spaniels (one 27 pounds one 16 pounds) many times. They love them and I feel they are just the right size for them.

Over all happy but they are very thin compared to other brands

Product of Bangladesh not "North & South America".Thin Bully Stick but my dog still enjoyed them.

Both my dogs love to get these treats. They don't ever stop chewing on these. I give them these bully sticks at least 2-3 times a week to keep them busy