Laura MercierCaviar Tightline Eyeliner: Long Lasting Color, Crease-proof, Waterproof, Gel-like Hydrating Formula, Perfect for Tightline, Lash Line + Waterline

I’ve been looking for a more precise eyeliner and this is it. Goes on very smooth in perfect lines. No smudging. I got the dark brown and will definitely be buying more colors.

One of the best tight eyeliners ever used. It glides on my margins and looks natural. I am a huge fan and will purchase all colors. Need sharpener which I also purchased.

Color perfect and goes on seamlessly..rich and easy to use and smudge..gave 4 stars because for price should come with pencil sharpener!! Otherwise better than Chanel pencil which does come with pencil.

This eyeline is awesome. So nice. Looks good, Goes on easily.

I love this product for its color and its smoothness. I unwittingly returned it twice, however, because I did not realize that it requires a pencil sharpener. I did not realize it because the outside looks plastic, not like a pencil. When I twisted the bottom (with difficulty), of course, nothing happened. There should be some kind of explanation that it requires a sharpener, which I learned from an employee at a brick and mortar cosmetic store.

The product itself is very nice, but having to sharpen it is a nuisance. ..it breaks, and also it gets dull/down in its wood casing with a sharp edge very quickly. If I had realized this eyeliner did not have a wind up from the bottom, I would not have bought it. All manufacturers seem to now have this wind up feature in their eye and lip liner packaging. I am surprised to one very infrequently which does not have this feature. Again, wouldn't have bought it if I had realized there was no wind-up in the packaging/

I’m an older woman so my eye lids are a bit of a challenge for both eyeliner and shadow. This stuff rocks! You can either put it on as liner or smudge it in for shadow. Doesn’t crease and looks great. Only one I now buy. Highly recommend

I love this product because the color is rich and it goes on smooth without pulling. I like that option of being able to smudge it for a different look.