Palladio Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Aubergine Creamy Slip Twist Up Pencil Eyeliner Smudge Proof Long Lasting Use No Sharpener Required

These lip pencils are excellent. Great colour, good staying power and glide on well.

Good for the price. Doesn’t give a completely smooth line but to be fair that could be my skin rather than the product.

Really great product and does exactly what it says. This is the second time I've bought this and it's great. It lasts all day, is very waterproof, goes on easily and is a great price. I'll be back again once this runs out.

I was somewhat disappointed the tip of the eyeliner colour-stick was not tapered causing the liner to go on thickly. I have gone back to using my pencil

Good quality , it will smudge if like me you have oily eyelids

I would have given this 5 stars but it snapped when i tried to apply it. the stick is very soft so only wind up a tiny amount, but the colour is saturated and has staying power. I would buy again.

This eye pencil lasts throughout the day, it is easy to apply and looks good.

Quite difficult to apply as quite greasy, not only is it easy to smudge, which I know is supposed to be a positive product benefit, but if a thicker line is applied you could end up looking like a panda within hours.