Thrive CausemeticsLiquid Lash Extensions Mascara, Tubing Thrive Mascara Lengthening, Volumizing & Curling, Smudge Proof, Washable, No Clumping or Flaking, Vegan & Cruelty Free, Brynn (Rich Black)

I love this stuff. I was a little worried about the price, but it was definitely worth it.This mascara gives me amazing length, almost like I’ve had lash extensions done. It lifts and separates every lash, giving a dramatic, falsie-like look without clumping. I had multiple people ask what brand I was using after purchasing.I have had zero issues with flakiness or crusting throughout the day. It stays put and doesn’t end up under my eyes, even if I’m sweating or outside in the heat and humidity.This mascara also has a nice, dark brown pigment and doesn’t smudge or run, even on my excessively moisturized skin. As marketed, it comes off easily with just water. The only thing to note is that if you put too much on and need to comb to separate, it can pull the mascara off.

OBSESSED!!! I got it in brown and black now because I love it so much! As you ladies know it’s hard to find a waterproof, All day wear, non clumping, lash extending, non transferring or raccoon eye giving mascara!! Well this one checks ALLLLL of this boxes and even better it’s lives up to the hype that’s going viral right now about how the tuning effect makes it soooo easy to remove WHEN you’re ready… I legit wore this intoThe pool and went under water and swam for over an hour and NONE came off and notEven a trace of it under my eyes. I’m never using anything else ever again!

I get so many compliments on this mascara. I will say you have to give it a week or so to air out. At first it can go on a bit clumpy and thick, but after a few uses it goes on very fine on each lash so that clumpy look goes away. My absolute favorite part about this mascara is you remove it - it comes off in solid clumps/flakes when you rinse with water. It is a pain to remove with makeup remover/oil. It just smears everywhere.

The absolute best tubing mascara! It is a little pricey but not only does it stay on flake free all day but lasts in the tube for many many months without drying out. I like tubing mascara because it stays on but washes off without residue very easily - no need for scrubbing or using mascara remover. It really doesn't flake or smudge but leaves lashes full and defined. I was happy to get it on amazon because it’s more convenient than ordering from thrive’s website (and arrives faster).

Pros: Goes on well without clumping. Appears to be waterproof and tearproof. Easy to apply. Cons: Was advertised as no flaking but that hasn’t been true for me. If I close my eyes for a few minutes, I’ll find a bunch of flakes under my eyes - like longer tubes. It’s okay as long as I don’t have to close my eyes for anything longer than a blink. Comes off pretty easily with makeup remover but all the little tubes are a pain to rinse or wipe away without extra effort.

I have both the black and the brown. I have long, visible lashes to begin with, so this is just enhancing my lashes. It does make them look longer and more defined. I prefer the brown because it makes my lashes look more natural than the black does. The black makes me look like I have false lashes, which doesn't work with my desire for a totally natural look for my make-up.I have not found that it left little clumps, though, sometimes it can stick a few lashes together to give the spider web look, which I personally don't like on me. To remove it, I just wet my fingers and gently rub just my lashes and it pulls off. They look like tubes when I am washing it off. I'll keep buying it.

I think I love this. I really want to. I’m amazed at how long my lashes look, which is a big deal for me because mine are so short and almost non— existent. I use a lash—growing serum and you can still hardly see them. I also love that it stays on forever without being waterproof. I hate waterproof mascara because I’m lazy and it’s so hard to get off. This just washes off with water, but stays put until then. I even slept in it and it looked great the next day. The photo’s from the am after. I was so impressed, I had to have photo evidence. I didn’t touch my face— there were no smudges or anything, still just beautiful long lashes the morning after. It also survived Midwestern humidity and an episode (or two) of menopausal tears.The only drawbacks for me that make me wonder if it’s worth it, are that it’s messy and it doesn’t take much to turn spidery (even though it may still look good from a distance—if you zoom in on the pic you’ll see they’re a teeny TammyFaye but still look ok overall). Overdoing it feels just one swipe away, where with other mascaras I can see it coming. And when no clumping, etc is a selling feature, I feel it shouldn’t be that easy. I don’t know, maybe I got an old tube and it would be worth buying direct from the cosmetic company. As far as being messy, I’m 48 and have been using mascara for many a decade now, but for some reason cannot keep this on just my lashes when applying this. It gets everywhere and I have to do a Qtip cleanup when I’m finished. Since I’m always running late and doing my makeup in a hurry (or at red lights), this is a big deal for me by adding extra time. Not only do I need to slow down to avoid being messy, now I need to clean up and then sometimes touch up the makeup I just wiped off while cleaning up.Are my lashes longer using this than using a primer and my regular mascara? I think so??But it would be close. I’d have to do a side—by—side comparison to really know. I’m torn about it overall. I want to really love it. The pros are ideal, but the cons might* be enough to ditch it. Time will tell.

Great mascara that does not clump or cake up. Also, it does not cause my lashes to fall out. Also, it does not have an awful smell and it washes off easily.