BenefitCosmetics Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer Shade 2.75

Sadly, after plucking my brows for so many years and developing a hormonal issue that causes hair loss, I have lost a lot of my natural eyebrows. My right brow is only about 25% real hair these days, and my left one about 50%, so I've tried many different brow products in order to not have a lopsided looking face due to missing brows. Most products just don't look natural enough for me, I'm not really a fan of the "artistic brow" that is so popular right now - I want my brows to look *real*, not have a faded "gradient" look to them (no offense to those who do, it just doesn't look attractive on me). Alas, most pencils just fall short of my needs. This one, however, is certainly among the best I've tried!First, I will say that my only true problem with this pencil is that it doesn't last as long (without fading or smearing) as my usual pencil, Maybelline Brow Temptation. It is better for fine detailing and makes it look like individual hairs are present, but it comes off sometimes on my pillow or smudges if I accidentally brush up against my brow - the Maybelline usually lasts several days before fading and doesn't even come off in the shower unless I scrub. The Benefit pencil needs more touch up, sometimes twice a day if I've been especially active. Still, this is an excellent pencil and my preferred daily pencil. I use it along with the Maybelline Brow Temptation, together they make my brows look almost as good as new. The Benefit gives me the detail around the edges that I desperately need to make it look like authentic brow hair, but the Maybelline gives me a longer lasting color so that when the Benefit inevitably fades, I'm not totally brow-less and embarrassed. Brow pencil teamwork.This pencil has a very fine point and seems pretty pigmented and creamy, it doesn't require pushing or tugging hard to get the lines to show up on my skin. It does seem to run out pretty quickly, and I'm on a tight budget and can't afford a lot of brow pencils...but that is a minor gripe. Unlike similar super-thin brow pencils, I've never had this pencil break while in use. A huge plus!If you like authentic looking brows or just crave precision, give this pencil a try. Just don't expect it to stay on if you get wet or have a small child or pet that is in your face all the time. I love this pencil so much that I'm still not removing any stars on the general review in spite of my few complaints against it, because this pencil is the king of detail and is such good quality.

I love this brow pencil! It marks very well and the attached brush make it looks so natural

I love this brow pencil - let’s get to some details.Pros:-Thin pencil allows for precision and hair-like strokes. Also I NEVER HAVE TO SHARPEN IT🥹-This color is great for me and lasts, even on hot & sweaty days!-Pairs well with brow gel. I use glossier’s “boy brow” after using the pencil and it’s perfect to offset the precision of the pencil and makes the brows look natural after filling them in.-The spoolie on the end is marvelous. I use it to brush my brows down and fill in the top part of my brows, then I brush my brows up and fill in the bottom part. Great for blending out if you do get a little heavy-handed and bold-fonted on yourself. 😂-Looks sleekCons:-ugh. I wish it was less expensive.Overall this product is worth it and reliable if that’s what you’re looking for. It’s a bit pricier but you know what you’ll get with it. I like knowing that my brows won’t be gone by the end of the day and this pencil ensures that! Yay!

great product, gives the looks of micro bladed brows without the cost. Not super water proof though

The plastic bag inside the package was cut open when I received it. The box was also half opened and crumpled but assume it could’ve just been damaged in shipping. The brow pencil itself seems fine so I’m keeping it but the cut open plastic bag definitely made me feel uneasy. I’ve used this brow pencil for two years before this so I know it’s a good brand

So easy to use, and thin enough to be able to fill in to have a full brow! Will continue to order this. Love it!

I’ve been using this brow pencil for a couple of weeks, and it has met my expectations. The color (#5 Deep) matches well with my brows, which can sometimes be difficult to achieve. The ultra-fine tip makes it easy to create natural, defined lines, making it a good option for those who need to fill in or make small adjustments.The pencil applies smoothly, which is a notable improvement compared to other brow products I’ve tried, like the Milani Brow Pencil. With this one, I found it easier to control and quicker to achieve the desired result, simplifying my routine.However, the price is on the higher end. I bought it on Amazon for $23 with a discount, but the regular price is 26, which may be too expensive for some. While the quality is strong, more affordable pricing or frequent discounts would make it a more accessible option, especially for budget-conscious users.

I have used this brow pencil for several years. It creates a natural look. I like the brush on the end. It helps even out the color. They offer multiple shades to choose from too.