Mally BeautyEvercolor Eyeshadow Stick - Mahogany Shimmer - Waterproof and Crease-Proof Formula - Easy-to-Apply Buildable Color - Cream Shadow Stick

Per usual, on Monday, Wednesday & Fridays, I go walking with my mom in my neighborhood. So one morning I decided to let her be the judge. I put on this eyeshadow stick & grabbed my sunglasses and off we went. Afterwards, she started talking to me & I pulled up my glasses on my head. She was startled & asked “What happened?” I had forgotten about my shadow and she told me that I had two black eyes!!! LoL! So I explained about my new eye shadow stick! We both laughed ;-)

This is the third color of these shadow sticks I've purchased and I love it! It's a great, deep, navy blue that is easy to create a thinner to thick line on the upper lid and is easy to smudge to create a lighter color or depth when layering colors. It stays well once set. I've gone swimming with other colors and they didn't smear all over my face but remained exactly as applied after a long swim! (I don't think I rubbed my eyes or dried my face with a towel but when I went into the bathroom I realized I had makeup on that I had forgotten about! Impressive!)Overall, great color and staying power! It's my new favorite eye makeup!

The color is beautiful, it’s very easy to apply. I have to say I don’t like that it stays a little sticky after being applied. Makes my eyelids stick together. Otherwise very nice.

Mally is known for saying the staying power of some of her makeup is "Bulletproof". I was a skeptic but I'm here to tell you IT WILL STAY on till you take it off. Removal is effortless. Comes off easily and I do wear waterproof mascara and it comes off fine.

Thistle is very pretty with green eyes - a purple heather shade, almost grey. If I liked this shade for more than just my crease it would be okay. Once this touches my lids it's immediately "no budge", very little blending possible! It's actually harder to get off than most!

I absolutely love this eyeshadow stick! But I have to be honest, the other formulas by this brand that are not matte— I did not like.The matte shadow sticks are very creamy, very blendable. They last long and I’m very satisfied with my purchase.

I love Mally products, their shiummery eyeshadow stick is no different. It goes on smoothly and stays on the lid all day (even when in hot sweaty weather), it does not smear and does not feel "tackky" or heavy on the eye lid. I love the beautiful neautral tine, it looks beautiful day or night and gives the eye a beautiful pop! I love that it glides on so easily you can wear it as eyeliner as well to highlioght the upper and lower lids. I am pretty sensitive to eye makeup and it doers not cause any irritation, one of the better eyeshadow sticks out there! Don't hesitate to buy!

I like the idea of an eyeshadow stick, just to make applying eyeshadow easier. A little too shiny for my taste, but works well.

Couldn't find single colours in supermarket, just poor quality powder stuff. This has great coverage simple to apply in pen format and lasts all day and evening. I would give it 5 apart from the odd range of colours - no greens or a gold one, etc. Arrived quickly and worked out cheaper than driving into town. Colour reproduction online is pretty reasonable. Shall be buying some more. I have sensitive, allergy-prone skin but this eyeshadow is very comfortable to wear.

It turns out darker than it looks... but to use on the edge of my lids.. it looks great and stay on.. no irritation and i have sensitive eyelids.This shade comes out like a medium mink colour with coffee and pinky tones.

I use this under and over lids as an eye liner. Good staying power

Vivid colour, quality product, great staying power

Good staying power and easy to apply