Perfect Pout Matte Retractable Gel Lip Liner Pencil, Rich Creamy Long Lasting Color, Well-Defined and Flawless Application, Vegan & Cruelty-Free - Red The Scene

I like this lip liner more than I anticipated I would. Goes on smooth. Looks good. I can't comment on the lasting power because I just got it. I meant to buy one of this color and one of another color but accidentally bought two of this color and one of the other color. I'm liking this so much so far, I'm not mad about it. One of the lip liners can live in my purse, one can live in my makeup drawers at home. I LOVE that the cap snaps on! I'm sick of lip liners getting uncaped in my in-purse-on-the-go makeup bag and the point getting smashed all over the other items in the bag. This lip liner went on smoothly, looks good, didn't cost an arm and a leg, is vegan, and the cap snaps on. If it lasts reasonably well on my lips there really isn't anything else I can say about this. It's a win.

I was pleasantly surprised by this lip pencil. The Perfect Pout pencils are excellent and stay where you put them. It's helpful to note the same is NOT true of Wet n Wild's other lip pencil lines. No luck with those at all. But these are as good or better than the more expensive pencils I have. They apply easily. The formula is neither soft or too firm. I wish they had many more colors, though. Great price!

Very nice product. It draws on smooth to my lips. I bought Bare to comment. Its a tad shade darker than I thought, but I like it. I think its a great buy

I loved it at first! It went on beautifully and the color was stunning! I used it alone, though, & maybe that's not how it's supposed to be used. As it wore on, only after minutes of wear, it sort of flaked/peeled off as I'd rub my lips together, looking quite ridiculous. I tried it again, this time just as a liner with lipstick over it & it worked a bit better that way. I still love the color but I'll have to find a lipstick that matches to get the original color effect I had with just the liner all over.

Was a little skeptical, color looked lighter than I expected upon opening it. But when I put it on! Wow! Vibrant! Beautiful color. Went on smoothly. Lasted all day. 10/10

Nice glide, pencil didn't break, but not mauve. I think of mauve as a medium dusty pink with purple undertones, neutral to cool-toned. Swatches online made it look like the perfect color but on me it looks more dark brown/orange than mauve. At least it was cheap. For reference I am very pale with neutral undertones. It might look more mauve on warm-toned skin with the warmer contrast but on cool/neutral skin it isn't cool enough. I was looking for a retractable, slightly darker version of NYX loud liner in Fierce Flirt. Will have to keep looking.

Perfect dupe for the Sacheu or Nyx lip stain/liner stains. Super subtle definition to make your lips look more luscious and the color stays WELL.

Smooth and creamy, great lip liner. I purchased "comes natural" and it is a wonderful nude shade. The pencil feels moist going on where it is a gel and my lips were very happy with it. The price is amazing, and the product is better than many priced much higher.