LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Always There Lengthening Mascara in Black - Defining, Curling, Buildable Formula Eye Makeup- Innovative Lengthening Brush - 1 count

Love all Laura Geller products

I really like this mascara, lashes look long and wears well. No smears, washes off with cleanser and water. No flaking. I’ll continue using.

It is a little clumpy getting out of the tube, that's why it got a 4 star. Once you get the brush cleaned off a bit it goes on nicely and extends your lashes.

I was looking for makeup for women over 40. I'm not sure if this is better for women my age or not, but the mascara is very good. When they say waterproof, they're not kidding. I tried makeup wipes to get this off and my regular face wash. Neither did much to remove this. You need actual eye makeup remover. Other than that, it's nice and thick, but not clumpy. Would definitely recommend.

If you take the time to add layers it will build length, but those layers are heavy so the lashes fall down and do not hold their shape. Plus, it flakes off during the day. After the 3rd order I believe I was receiving old product because the mascara dried out much faster than previous orders. I finally found a better product and stopped using this.

I've bought this same product directly from Laura Geller website, so I know what it 'should' be like. Normally this is one of the better mascaras I've ever used, but over the last few months, they're constantly out of stock on the main LG website. I finally turned to Amazon to locate some. They arrived quickly and the packaging was intact. I didn't check them right away, not expecting a problem. I put them in my 'future makeup' box, tightly closed and away from heat, light and moisture. It was just over a month later when I opened one of these up. Instead of coming out of the tube with that swish sound and the brush being moist with product, the brush almost sounded like a dry bristle moving in the tube and there was barely any product on the brush. I put it back in and out several time and still not much product. On my lashes, the brush nearly drags and doesn't deposit much product on my lashes, and definitely not lengthening as it normally does. Anyway, I went to amazon to try to exchange and was told it was too late (more than 30 days apparently) and I must deal with Laura Geller directly. So I've contacted them and hope they will make this right. As I said, normally this is a great product and I was really disappointed in this batch. One week later......after several emails with LG, they say they can't remedy issues with purchases from the LG Amazon store. Maybe someone else is running the LG Amazon store?? So now I'm just out of luck. So beware, if you buy from the LG Amazon store....if you're late in returning/exchanging, too bad.

Truly waterproof! Love this mascara. Separates lashes wonderfully & lasts all day. Highly recommend!!

Long lasting mascara