tarte tartelette XL tubing mascara – Lash Extensions in a Tube with Peptide, Extra-Bold Buildable Lifted Length & Volume, Smudge-Proof Longwear, Easy-to-Remove, Vegan & Cruelty-Free

I used Thrive Causemetics mascara for years and thought that was pretty good, but I always wished that it was a little wetter, that it didn’t have phenoxyethanol and that it didn’t slightly irritate my eyes. Tarte Tartelette is everything I ever wanted Thrive mascara to be: First of all, it’s a true and very good tubing mascara. It’s wet enough not to have ANY clumps whatsoever and to coat my lashes evenly and perfectly, yet dry enough that it’s not a goopy mess that makes it so that my lashes can’t hold a curl. It doesn’t flake. It lengthens my lashes beautifully. It comes off easily with just water. It looks perfectly fine in the morning if I don’t wash it off at night. The brown color is a rich chocolate shade that complements my autumn coloring perfectly, not just a brownish black that looks essentially black once on. It’s the only tuning mascara I’ve ever tried that’s actually buildable; two coats looks dramatic, not clumpy and botched. I look like I have lash extensions. All this AND it doesn’t have phenoxyethanol. I absolutely love it. I have found the holy grail of mascaras.

This mascara is so nice. It goes on without clumping and looks nice and natural, yet at the same time gives a nice full eyelash. Easy to take off and doesn't rip out your lashes like other mascara. Even the tube just feels nice and heavy and elegant. So much better than other mascara brands I've tried, and I've tried MANY. Just a good product that you won't be disappointed to buy. I was hesitant to spend so much at first, as I usually don't---but let me tell you, it was soooo worth it. I'll never go back to lesser expensive brands!!! I don't have to apply multiple layers to achieve the look in going for, and it dries quickly. It doesn't smear. Doesn't flake. All around just a very nice product. 10/10 stars for me!!!! I'll post photos soon!

The best mascara I’ve ever used. It doesn’t give dramatic lashes, so I love it for every day use. Stays on all day with no smudging. And if it does flake, it’s time to buy a new one. 10/10 recommend. I’m on my 4th one.

This is a great mascara. The tubing really works and is my favorite type of mascara. It comes off easily with warm water but does not smudge throughout the day. I will say that the tube that came when I ordered the product was smaller than I expected, but that was probably because I ordered the travel size by accident. Overall this is a good product that I will order again.

Favorite mascara. Love the way the mascara come off. So it doesn’t cause any damage to the lashes and my eyes aren’t a mess after. Love the brush, makes eyelashes look so long!

Best all in one. Gives me the heaviest application and longest lashes with the least effort.

Japanese tubing mascara is by far the best mascara to use. It is far superior to traditional flaky mascara. The tubing mascara stays on until you wash your face and the mascara just slides off. It is so much healthier for your lashes and their growth. Kevyn Aucoin the famed make up artist, who has sadly passed, introduced the tubing mascara more than 20 years ago. And Tarte has done a terrific job with the product. I was glad to find it in brown. If you’re looking for long, lush, separated lashes, this is the mascara for you.

Let me say I never write reviews but I can't stop thinking about how amazing this mascara is. I've used waterproof drugstore mascara my whole adult life but I've been seeing these " tubing" mascaras and was curious. This mascara doesn't flake, smudge, comes off 100% clean -no black cast after removing, doesn't irritate my eyes ( contact user), no caking no clumping. I've been changed, this is the only mascara I'll be using from now on.