Yard Butler Manual Lawn Coring Aerator - Core Aerator for Lawn Care - Loosen Compacted Soil - Dethatcher Garden Tool for Lawn Health - Plug Core Soil Aeration Tool - Gray, 37 Inches

After stressing for longer than id like to admit and spending way more time than id like to admit looking for the "perfect" manual aerator i ended up going with this one and i am extremely glad i did. While every yard is different, Mine absolutely has clay in it. Im not smart enough to say its a lot of clay or a little bit of clay but it definitely is a mix of clay and this worked perfectly. I used it after it had rained some so the ground was wet but it worked better than expected. It absolutely pulled cores out of the ground. Also it was very easy to use, i went with 2 tines because i was worried about it being difficult to press into the ground but it was very easy. I am 5'11 roughly 175lbs. I would recommended people buy this for sure.

Its really good very sturdy and works as expected very happy with the purchase

Bought one a few years ago at a Lowe's or Osh that I thought was the Hound Dog branded "Turf Hound" but it looked almost identical to the "Yard Butler" instead, so I don't know if the companies are related or maybe I just had a brain fart and filed the memory incorrectly. It worked well enough that I wore that down to nubs (see photo comparing the old one to new) thanks to hard clay soil that had to be pretty moist to penetrate making the tips rust, chip,or bend into the tube, and then having to file or grind the ends back to a functional point. When this seasons plugs were all coming out stumpy, I figured I could use a replacement and wondered if there might be a tool that didn't clog as much as that had. I think that in certain clays, it's inevitable, though you can minimize it by working it only after it's been watered and oiling the tines before and after using the tool.I have tried ones with more tines, and they are much harder to push into the ground since I am only 5'2 and 130lbs, so the two tines works better for me. I also find the height of the handle appropriate on this one, and the T design is comfortable because I can switch feet easily, without knocking a knee into the sides of the handle. I'm not sure how this compares with using the Hound Dog model, except that the center handle might help with pivoting the thing from side to side more easily when necessary, or perhaps the stepping space might be easier to access on the Dog version because it's more open. But then again, I also find it helpful that the shape above the step on the Butler helps ensure I don't just step THROUGH it and miss planting it down firmly.I did try the red one with thicker tines and the step "lifting bar" (see pics for side by sides) in hopes that it would be less clog prone, but found that the shape made it noteably more difficult to push into the ground than the slightly thinner and longer tines of the Butler. It may be because they are thicker, even though they are tapered, or maybe because they are cut square instead of at an angle like the Butler, which slid much more deeply and smoothly into the ground. Though the other one DID seem to be less likely to pack up with soil IN the tines, it also was much more problematic in dirt clogging AROUND the them instead (see pics). Go figure...The step bar on the red one didn't really add anything useful to the process for me, as it wasn't really helpful to try and use my foot to pick up the tool. It actually seemed a bit more in the way when switching feet, which I did much more frequently than trying to lift it with the foot. Some may prefer the thicker grips on the red one, but my hands are pretty large and I had no issues with the thinner ones.The one clear advantage of the red one is really probably the color itself, as I did have trouble locating the green Yard Butler on the lawn if I stepped away from it. The red is totally obvious to spot immediately.Lastly, I also preferred the resulting plug length of the Butler. The thickness of the other was beaten by the depth of extracted material with Yard Butler. (Last picture shows all 3 YB cores on the left vs 3 shorter of the other tool on the right). Definitely get an extra inch or more with the YB tool.YB beats the spike sort and more complicated coring setups on manual tools. There might be some real advantage to a rolling disc type on ebay, but it costs much more. If you have a large enough yard, though, it might be worth the cost over renting something powered, especially if you don't have something that needs a riding mower in size. My mom's lawn is probably 2000 sq ft, and it can be a workout and a long day to step core the whole thing alone, but I do it a little at a time whenever I visit and it's fine because the tool is always available and quiet enough to use in the middle of the night so the summer heat isn't overwhelming.I dig it. And it really does improve the lawn significantly. If I see it's getting a bit tired looking, I know it's time to step some air into thr soil and it thickens up nicely. For the money, it's a win in my book.Id like to try the other design I saw on Amazon too, which ejects the cores on the SIDE of the tine instead of through the top, as that might be less likely to pack into a clog, but I would want to know it was really better before spending twice as much money on it. For now I am doing fine with this and maybe will try the other if it wears down so far in a few years as the last one did. ..

I'm glad I bought this. I have "soil" with a lot of rocks and some clay and wasn't sure this would work. I've only used it here (Upstate NY) in the Spring when the ground was fairly soft, but I was able to easily penetrate the soil and the plugs are coming out the top so I only have to push the last bit out when I'm done. I recommend an automated solution for a large area, but this is great for small spaces. It penetrates easier and I'm able to cover much more ground than I expected. And it's nice and sturdy.

It will definitely put holes in the ground, doesn’t really discharge any dirt though it all just clogs up the holes. I have a lot of clay which may be the issue, have tried on wet and dry soil with the same results

The media could not be loaded. Works great! I hadn’t paid to have my lawn aerated in years as I have backyard chickens, trees and other plants that I didn’t want damaged. So with this hand aerator, I was able to control where I aerated (avoiding tree roots, etc) and how much I wanted. It is not hard to do but it does take time and can be a little bit of a work out. I am only 5’1” and had no problems with it other than getting a blister so wear gloves! I aerated heavily and my yard is looking good so it needed it. This is well worth the $, is built well and not heavy to work with. I did have some soil stick to it a couple of times because it’s clay and it was just a little too wet (end of February and a few days after a snow fall) so I poked the soil out and cleaned with with a long cylindrical brush. So make sure that the soil is NOT too wet not too dry when doing this. I only wish I had bought this earlier.

I have an Earth Machine compost bin I got from my county and it's great but I needed something to help me turn it and mix it. I looked at the (not correct term, but) ones that curve at the bottom, but worried that they would bend or break. Found the Yard Butler stick with wings and it works great! It was easy to push to the bottom of an 80 gal bin and I pulled up sticks that I had placed in the bottom when initially put it together. My current temp here is about 30F degrees. And everything is frozen, however I had no problem getting the YB down deep into my compost bin. I was able to stir the compost, bring up stuff from the bottom, mix in stuff from the top (i.e. carbon I had added). I was amazed. Sometimes the wings don't open or 1 wing doesn't open - but that's usually stuff that's really compacted and wet, so to me it's not a big deal, it's not like the wings won't open or get stuck closed. I am able to mix everything up really well. I can't wait for it to get warmer and see how it does over the summer.

Tool gets the job done even in clay soil. This product is sturdy and seems like it would be sturdier than the other products I looked at. It is tough work for a 1000 sqft yard. Not for the faint of heart!